Writing hands HERO logo  The Health Enhancement Research Organization  
Pen on Graph  
HERO is a national leader in the creation of  Employee Health Management: Research, Education, Policy, Strategy, Leadership and Infrastructure.
                                                                   MEMBER LOGIN

Accolade, Inc.
Affinia Group
American Council of Engineering Companies Life/Health Trust 
American Council on Exercise
American Heart Association
American Psychological Association
American Specialty Health
Aon Hewitt Consulting
BAE Systems Inc.
Barry-Wehmiller Companies, Inc.
Best Doctors
Blue Cross & Blue Shield of MA
Blue Cross & Blue Shield of MN
Boeing Company
Bravo Wellness, LLC
Central Michigan University
Corning Incorporated
Corporate Health Partners 
DTE Energy
Dow Chemical Company
Eastman Chemical Company
Engaged Health Solutions
Ergotron, Inc.
Findley Davies
Gardant Global Inc.
Goldman Sachs
Health to You
HealthSTAT, Inc.
Healthyroads, Inc.
Hennepin County HealthWorks
Hooper Holmes
Howard County Public School System
HUB International
Humana Vitality
INTEGRIS Health, Inc.
Intermountain Healthcare/Selecthealth
Interactive Health
Johnson & Johnson
Kaiser Permanente
Kimberly-Clark Corporation
Life Time Fitness
Lincoln Industries
LL Bean
Lockheed Martin
Lockton Companies
Marsh & McLennan Agency
MasterBrand Cabinets
Mayo Clinic
Medical Mutual of Ohio
MediFit Corporate Services
The MetroHealth System
MHN/Health Net
Michigan State University
National Academy of Sports Medicine
National Security Agency
NextEra Energy
Norton Healthcare
Ohio State University
Onlife Health
Oregon Center for Applied Science
Performance pH
Preventure Inc.
Prudential Financial
Quest Diagnostics
RedBrick Health
Sanofi, US
Schwan Food Company
Shape Up
SeeChange Health Solutions
Spafinder Wellness, Inc.
St. Jospeh Health
State of Nebraska
StayWell Health Management
Target Corporation
Towers Watson
Truven Health Analytics
Tufts Health Plan
Universities Wellness Alliance of Kentucky
University of Alabama
University of Arizona
University of Iowa
University of Michigan
University of Minnesota
US Preventive Medicine
UPMC Health Plan
VAL Health
Vanderbilt University
Virgin Pulse
WebMD Health Services
Wells Fargo
Yale University

Scorecard Background

The HERO Employee Health Management (EHM) Best Practices Scorecard is designed to help employers, providers, and other stakeholders learn about and determine EHM best practices. Earlier versions of the Scorecard have been available since 2006. The Scorecard was developed in consultation with authoritative sources on EHM best practices, including The Health Project’s C. Everett Koop National Health Awards criteria, the WELCOA Well Workplace Awards criteria (Platinum level), Partnership for Prevention’s Health Management Initiative Assessment, and the Department of Health and Human Services’ Partnership for Healthy Workforce 2010 (PHW2010) criteria. Selected elements from these sources were considered in the original construction of the Scorecard; however, most Scorecard content originated with the HERO Think Tank Task Force for Metrics. This rigorous development process was continued with the design of the current Scorecard (Version 3.0), which included input and peer review from HERO Think Tank members, Mercer Total Health Management Practice leaders and other national authorities on EHM best practice programs.

How the Scoring System Was Developed

A panel of EHM authorities from a variety of organizations assisted in developing the scores using a consensus-building exercise.  We began with a proposed maximum score of 200.  Each panel member was asked to distribute these 200 points across the six sections of the Scorecard, based on their judgment about the relative importance of each foundational component of a successful EHM program (“successful” was defined as able or likely to improve total health care spend). The maximum section scores were then distributed across the items within each section using the same criteria.  Finally, the maximum item scores were distributed across the individual responses in each item.  The panel members’ scores were aggregated and either the mode or average (mean) score, as appropriate, was used as the final score.

As with previous versions of the Scorecard, the contributors to the V3.0 scoring system engaged in robust debate and discussion. Since there was limited solid research evidence to support or refute the  impact of many individual programmatic elements on health care cost trend, the contributors offered their proposed scores based on the best research and anecdotal evidence available, recognizing that more definitive research will inform ongoing refinement of the relative weighting of the scores. For now, the contributors consider elements with higher weighted scores to be among the more promising  EHM practices but believe these practices can achieve their greatest impact only as part of a comprehensive EHM strategy.

Click to see the maximum scores assigned to each section, item and response in the Scorecard.

Invitation to Contribute Feedback

If you would like to communicate with the HERO Think Tank about this version of the Scorecard, please do so by emailing info@the-hero.org, with ‘Scorecard’ in the subject box. We welcome your reactions, comments, and suggestions for improving the Scorecard, as well as ideas for applications of the Scorecard. All replies will be acknowledged and considered confidential. Thank you!

HERO Scorecard Contributors

Scorecard Revisions Team Members 

  David Anderson, PhD, LP
StayWell Health Management
Jessica Grossmeier, PhD, MPH
StayWell Health Management
  Annemarie Harte
Sue Lewis, MEd
Lewis Health Strategies LLC
  Steven P. Noeldner, PhD
LaVaughn Palma-Davis, MA
University of Michigan
  Mimi Tun
Beth Umland
  Fred Williams
Quest Diagnostics

Scorecard Outcomes Team Members 

  Ed Framer, (Chairman)
Lloyd Herlong
Eastman Chemical Company
  David Anderson, PhD, LP
StayWell Health Management
Doug Knoop, MD
HealthSTAT, Inc
  Michael Brennan, MS, MBA
The Boeing Company
Steven Noeldner, PhD
  Jeff Dobro, MD
Towers Perrin
Michael P. O'Donnell, PhD, MPH,MBA American Journal of Health Promotion
  Tom Fariss, MD
Kimberly-Clark Corporation
Nico Pronk, PhD
  Ron Goetzel, PhD
Thomson Reuters
Seth Serxner, PhD
  Dan Gold, PhD
Beth Umland
  Jessica Grossmeier, PhD, MPH
StayWell Health Management
Ben Hamlin, MPH

Additional Key Contributors & Advisors

  Bill Whitmer, MBA
Sue Willette
StayWell Health Management
  Richard Babcock
John Harris, M.Ed.
  Paul Berger, MD
Yvonne Ingram-Rankin, MS
  Diane Cheatham, RNC, BSN
AtlantiCare Health Plans
Kara Koss, MPH
  Ralph Colao, FAWHP
Ron Loeppke, MD
US Preventive Medicine
  K. Andrew Crighton, MD, CPE
Prudential Financial
Bob Soroosh, MBA
Affinia Group
  William Greer, MBA
Kellogg Company
Mary Anna Weklar, MHA
Sutter Health Partners
HERO, 7400 Metro Blvd, Suite 270, Edina, MN 55439
Phone: 952-835-4257 FAX: 952-831-0848 ©HERO 2009